Skip to main content

Why Stellaris diplomacy feels so bloodless

By

I'm still playing stellaris in almost all my gaming time, and enjoying it, primarily because I've found and either used or stolen ideas from a bunch of mods that fix problems that are fixable.

To be honest, some of these I like because they straddle the line carefully between moving it more toward a pure 4X game and losing the fresh voice in 4X coming from the Paradox grand strategy sauce. Some of the resource constraints pot such limits on early strategies that you are forced to let the early game become just the randomization step for a mostly static patchwork of essentially equivalent-powered empires, so the midgame looks just like one of their historical games. But removing them entirely is too much; I dial then down so the decisions of the early game become significant ones about how to grow my empire - how much physical expansion, how much infrastructure, how much defense - instead of meaningless firefighting while waiting for the static nap to evolve.

But all that said, I'm realizing more and more that it's in the diplomacy - the very heart of what should be Paradox's homeland, that I'm feeling the worst about the game. They've admitted that the lack of visible personality or goals in the opponents us a big problem, but there's also a horrible lack of options. Basically, if you are in conflict with another error, you can either declare war or suck it up. You can't make demands, you can't make threats, you can't warn that something they are doing will lead to war.

Most of this would require a lot of development time, and i do hope that Paradox's reputation for great ongoing improvements will address that. But why on Earth it in the stars is there o option for an ultimatum? Give me that colony you just started along the border, it I will take it by force? As things are now, I just have to declare war, and in doing that there's no advantage to keeping the war goals in the declaration small. In fact, because they will be free to do whatever they like for ten years after the war ends, a limited war is a really bad idea - you need to hurt their infrastructure enough that they will take those years to rebuild.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

New Stellaris patch - the power of a name, the sadness of the lame

By
Paradox just shipped a free update to Stellaris featuring a story written by Alexis Kennedy. That's enough to get me to think about trying it again. I checked out the patch notes, and I see a lot of clean up of things that bugged me about the game. But wait a minute. These are the notes for the fourth major patch, and they clean up things that were wrong (sometimes obviously) from the start? I'll chalk it up to development priorities; certainly there was a lot missing that needed to be added, and since the main point of the game is to look like a 4X while actually being a 1X bolted on to a standard Paradox set-piece political game I guess problems with the other three Xes were not as high a priority. I'm certain I'll try Stellaris again at some point, especially if they get more good writers in on making snippets for it. But I doubt it will ever really be my kind of game.
Post a Comment
Read more

GW2 Heart of Thorns, after some serious play time

By
The first week or two after Heart of Thorns went live, I was a bit disappointed. Playing on, first because four of my friends and I always play together on Mondays, I got a little more of a philosophical handle on how the expansion changes the game, and I'm no longer ambivalent about having bought it - I love some parts, and I just had to learn that the "different kinds of fun as you feel like it" game design is now painted in broader strokes - especially you should only go into one of the new zones if you feel like the activity that is going on in it. Roughly speaking, HoT adds four things to the game: A new character class, a new "elite" subclass for each class, a new form of progression at L80, and a bunch of new zones with their story. Of these, the zones are the most visible and important, and the mastery tracks are the most novel and IMO successful, so I'll leave those for last. In thinking about these changes together, I think I see a philosophica...
Post a Comment
Read more